After the wise and charming Where’d You Go Bernadette? I really wanted to delve into this author’s back catalog and be as similarly enthralled. Alas, Maria Semple’s debut novel This One Is Mine lacks the wit of WYGB, instead drawing on a cast of unlikeable characters who spend most of the book being mean or stupid or selfish, or some combination of the three. There are glimmers of the compassion that’s such a large part of WYGB, but the way this novel is written strips the characters of pathos, and makes it read a bit like The Corrections-lite (which some people might consider a good thing, ech.) I get the Anna Karenina homage, and like the idea of it as an updated version of that sans the long digressions into agriculture, but I don’t think it works on its own (and regular readers know my opinion of AK, which doesn’t help this book any either.)
Sep 11 2015
This One Is Mine by Maria Semple
- By Doreen Sheridan in Doreen, Literature
-
September 11, 2015
Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2015/09/11/this-one-is-mine-by-maria-semple/
Recent Posts
- How To Survive The End Of The World by Katy Doughty April 27, 2026
- Paladin’s Strength by T. Kingfisher April 26, 2026
- The Element of Fire by Martha Wells April 25, 2026
- Tantalizing Tales — April 2026 — Part Four April 24, 2026
- Was That Normal? by Alex Potts April 23, 2026
- Hafsa’s Way by Aisha Saeed April 22, 2026
- More Spring Speculative Fiction by Beloved Authors! April 21, 2026
- Table Titans Club: Sneak Attack by Scott Kurtz April 20, 2026
- Chevengur by Andrey Platonov April 19, 2026
- City of Oranges by Adam LeBor April 18, 2026
Contributors
Categories
Tag Cloud
Al
Alternate History
Art
Auf Deutsch
Autobiography
Children's
Doreen
Doug
Dystopia
Eastern Europe
England
Excerpt
Fabulous Ones
Fantasy
Feminism
Fiction
Games
Germany
Graphic Novel
Graphic Novels
Historical Fiction
History
Horror
Hugo Finalist
Humor
LGBTQIA
Literature
Middle Grade
Mystery
Mythology
Non-fiction
Novella
Poetry
Politics
Religion
Romance
Russia
Science
Science Fiction
Short Stories
Süddeutsche Zeitung
Tantalizing Titles
Thriller
Urban Fantasy
Young Adult