A Prayer for Owen Meany by John Irving

I just finished this book, and now I am almost speechless. I laughed out loud through the first half of it, which now seems irreverent and almost blasphemous considering the way it turned out, but about halfway through it I perceived that it was heading toward some kind of mysterious and profound resolution, and after that it stopped being funny and became heart-wrenching. This book is an extraordinary creation that in its own homespun way tackles some of the deepest issues of existence, without ever descending into ponderousness or pretentiousness. There is, of course, a strong dose of the author’s liberal politics sprinkled throughout, but the author, or at least the narrator, has the good taste not to take himself too seriously, and the contempt he pours on the self-righteousness of the ’60’s antiwar movement is obviously sincere and unfeigned. But this book is so much more than merely political; it is one of the most profound expressions of spirituality I have ever read. This is undoubtedly the opus magnus of one of the most gifted novelists of our time.

Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2014/12/16/a-prayer-for-owen-meany-by-john-irving/

The Days of Anna Madrigal by Armistead Maupin

Anna Madrigal

In this ninth Tales of the City novel, The Days of Anna Madrigal, Armistead Maupin is content to show his characters being themselves. That’s no mean feat, for it requires creating characters who are both believable and interesting in themselves, and sustaining it over one or several books. Many authors do not appear to have the confidence to allow their characters to develop in a way that appears natural. I even thought that Maupin was one such author — in the middle books of the set, the characters‘ personal histories and interrelationships go from mildly Baroque to floridly rococo — but in the last two, he has simplified his sprawling cast (even as a new generation has come on stage), and concentrated on characters who are at the heart of the long work.

First was Mary Ann Singleton, the original Midwestern girl whose tales of moving to San Francisco started everything. Mary Ann in Autumn charted her return, many years later, following a career back on the East Coast and a divorce, as she fends off cancer and makes peace with people and places. Now Anna Madrigal, once the landlady and den mother to the novels’ cast of characters, has reached the advanced age of 92.

He settled in the other chair. “I talked to Anna last night. She sounded good.”
Shawna shrugged. “She’s okay.”
“What’s the matter?”
“She’s ninety-fucking-two, Dad.”
“She’s not sick, though?”
“No—just kinda … packing up.”
He took that in glumly, saying nothing.
She stroked the arm of the chair, comforting something inanimate in lieu of the more vulnerable human alternative. “We have to honor it, Dad. Anything else would just make her feel alone. We have to—”
She didn’t finish, so he did it for her. “‘Drive her to the station and wave good-bye.'” He was quoting Mrs. Madrigal herself. Their long-ago landlady had hit them with that sobering train metaphor a few years back. They were not to make a fuss, she had said then, but she wouldn’t mind having “family on the platform.”

While the end of Anna’s days permeates the book, it is anything but an elegy, and she is as cheerfully irreverent as she ever was. She’s also keen to wrap up a few pieces of unfinished business, and this, as much as anything, drives the story. It also enables Maupin to tell of some of Anna’s earliest days in flashbacks set in small-town Nevada when Anna was a Depression-era child. Nine books later, readers are still learning new things about Mrs. Madrigal.

The present-day story eventually takes most of the characters to Burning Man, an annually temporary colony of the Bay Area in the Nevada desert. For people who want to see them, there are implied contrasts between the community of fate when Anna was a teen and the intentional community created by and for Burning Man; there are also contrasts within the people participating in the Burning Man event, a way for Maupin to show the creativity of the event, as well as the foibles and absurdities that come along with it.

Mostly, however, the book offers a chance to spend more time with people that readers have known for 30 years or more, people who have now led full lives and are reflecting on them, even while setting forth new chapters.

Mary Ann had sent [Michael] on his way that night [in the 1970s]. Squeaky clean out of Cleveland, she had already begun to accept his brand-new randiness as if it were her own. “Go find a nice billy goat,” she had told him with a playful shove, and in some ways that was the version of her he still maintained, the smart girl creeping up on adventure with one eye covered, not the liberal rich lady from Woodside taking Zumba lessons at the Zen Center. He had come to like the later-day Mary Ann, but never with the intimacy of old. She probably felt the same about him—that stodgy old queen fussing in his garden, holed up with his younger husband in the Castro.

Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2014/12/16/the-days-of-anna-madrigal-by-armistead-maupin/

The House of Hades by Rick Riordan

One of the nice things about not being in a book’s target audience is being able to stand back a bit more and see what the author is up to, what’s happening structurally within a book or series, to generally chew on it a bit more. The House of Hades reaches its main intended audience perfectly: Kid One tore through it in just a few days, never mind school or much of anything else. A whole bunch of people are growing up with Percy Jackson and his friends as formative reading experiences, and I think that’s great. They’re fun, and they work well on several different levels.

Continue reading

Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2014/12/15/the-house-of-hades-by-rick-riordan/

The Merchant of Venice by William Shakespeare

Some people come away from this play with the impression that it is anti-semitic, but Shakespeare puts such eloquent defenses and rebuttals in the mouth of Shylock, on behalf of himself and his people, that for me the charge does not ring true.  The more serious theme of this drama is the balance, at times the conflict, between law and mercy.  Of course Shakespeare makes the Christian worldview prevail, yet ironically he does this by upholding the letter of the law, in a way that utterly confounds the legalistic Shylock.  There are some memorable lines in this play, such as Launcelot’s speculation that converting Jews to Christianity will drive up the price of pork, and Antonio’s fit of melancholy at the beginning of the story, and the playful repartee between lover and beloved shows Shakespeare in his usual fine form.  The tale of the three caskets is a side plot that seems a tad out of place, and its outcome smacks slightly of insincerity, since the one who hazards all gains all without paying a price…but obviously Shakespeare deems it unseemly that his lovers should be paupers.  Yet this is a marvelous play, entirely deserving of its reputation, and every time I revisit it I am quite enchanted by it.

Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2014/12/15/the-merchant-of-venice-by-william-shakespeare/

Carpe Demon (Demon-Hunting Soccer Mom #1) by Julie Kenner

The twists are quite clever, and the main character really is, as promised, like an alternate universe Buffy if she’d retired to the suburbs. A somewhat slight book, but not an unintelligent piece of escapist fiction.

Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2014/12/13/carpe-demon-demon-hunting-soccer-mom-1-by-julie-kenner/

Game Changer by Mihir Bose

Mihir Bose is a terrific investigator, resourceful, thorough and intrepid. The amount of work he’s put into uncovering the facts and organizing the data is just astonishing. I only wish his writing skills were up to that standard. Beyond even the silly mistakes that appear more a result of slapdash composition than anything else, the chapters which involve large numbers of people — with the chapters on satellite rights and the formation of the league being particularly notable for this — are excruciatingly tedious and unnecessarily complicated reads. Not everyone can write a sports book as consistently engrossing as Moneyball, but a more demanding editor would have given us a superlative book, instead of this one, that alternately delights and drags, educates and irritates. Terrific if you’re looking to learn more about the English Premiere League but of little appeal to the casual reader.

Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2014/12/11/game-changer-by-mihir-bose/

A Monarchy Transformed: Britain 1603-1714 by Mark Kishlansky

The introduction conveys the author’s enthusiasm for the study of this period, but the expectation of excitement rapidly peters out in what amounts to a rather dull narrative. Nevertheless, this was a time of tremendous change and development in British history. Aside from the Civil War, the Commonwealth, the Restoration, and the Glorious Revolution, this was also the period during which Britain became the supreme maritime power in the world, and it was also the period during which England and Scotland formally united into the modern nation of Britain. The extraordinary scientific developments of this period are omitted; this book focuses exclusively on political developments, and I found it rather dry reading. But it is an educational if not exactly fascinating account.

Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2014/12/08/a-monarchy-transformed-britain-1603-1714-by-mark-kishlansky/

Finding Poland by Matthew Kelly

Did you know there was an Association of Poles in India? Did you even have the faintest idea that there had been Poles by the thousand in India during the Second World War and in the first few years afterward? I certainly didn’t, and I know a thing or two about Poles and Poland.

Which is to say that I figured right in my previous notes about Finding Poland by Matthew Kelly when I wrote that there would be “more for me to just enjoy in the other four-fifths of the book, as Kelly tells a story of what happened to members of his family.” Kelly, a historian at the University of Southampton, applied his professional training to the Polish side of his family. His narrative centers on his great-grandparents who settled in the eastern part of interwar Poland, in Hruzdowa, a small settlement in what is now northwestern Belarus. That’s a part of the interwar republic that went to the USSR under the Hitler-Stalin Pact, and following the Soviet invasion in 1939, Kelly’s forbears were deported in April 1940. His great-grandfather Rafał was most likely captured and taken prisoner by the Red Army. His great-grandmother, along with her two daughters, was packed into a railroad car and taken, along with thousands of other Poles from the borderlands, to serve the state in Kazakhstan.
Continue reading

Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2014/12/08/finding-poland-by-matthew-kelly/

Parkinson’s Disease: A Guide for Patients and Families by William Weiner MD, Lisa Shulman MD, and Anthony Lang MD

A good source of information with a surprisingly optimistic outlook on a really terrible neurological disorder. There is still no cure, but there are drug treatments that can alleviate the symptoms. I hate to dwell on such an irrelevant detail, but there was significant commentary on the effects of Parkinson’s on the patient’s sex life. Well, hello, I have no sex life and have never had a sex life; am I supposed to regard that as a medical problem and seek treatment for it? Silliness aside, there was a lot of interesting stuff about the brain and the nervous system, and contrary to what is popularly believed, there is NO evidence at all that stem cells have any therapeutic effect. There was a long and detailed evaluation of the effectiveness of various drug treatments and surgical treatments; this was probably the most useful information in the book. The causes of the disease remain unknown. I wouldn’t say this book prepared me for med school, but it did educate me considerably.

Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2014/12/05/parkinsons-disease-a-guide-for-patients-and-families/

The Slow Regard of Silent Things by Patrick Rothfuss

What to say that Laura hasn’t already?

This story is a week in the life of a minor character, minor in Rothfuss’ other works, that is, and I think that it’s a good example of a writer doing something interesting because he doesn’t feel constrained to follow that larger story. It isn’t trying to be the story of someone who changed the world (though Auri might have, and might yet, just not so as anyone else is likely to notice), it’s not an epic quest, it’s not a clash of great principles or even much of a clash at all. Among all of the things that this story is not, the story takes the freedom to be just what it is.

Auri lives under the library and other parts of the city from Rothfuss’ other novels, The Name of the Wind and The Wise Man’s Fear. She was apparently once a magician and now leads a furtive, precarious existence. It’s not clear whether her heightened sense of objects and their belonging is real, whether it’s the result of whatever mishap led to her underground life, or whether that’s a meaningful distinction at all in the context of the story.

Naming, sorting, placing: these are magical tasks, and that is what she spends most of her days and nights doing. There are rituals within her life, and her life as a whole is also a ritual.

Rothfuss says in the afterword, “I let the story develop according to its own desire. I didn’t force it into a different shape or put anything into it just because it was supposed to be there. I decided to let it be itself.” I’m glad that he did, and I’m glad that he has the market clout to get an unusual story like this one into print. I wouldn’t want this off-kilter tale of heightened attention to be the only kind of fantasy book around, but I am glad that it is there and stretching the boundaries of what publishers will print just a little bit.

Permanent link to this article: https://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2014/12/03/the-slow-regard-of-silent-things-by-patrick-rothfuss-2/